Bali Discovery Tours: Homepage
Bali Hotels, Bali Villas and Bali News from balidiscovery.com
Home Bali Contact Bali Practicalities Bali News Bali Services Bali Transportation Bali Sports Bali Excursions Bali Villas Bali Hotels
Home · News · A Warning About Warnings
Bali Hotels, Bali Villas and Bali News from balidiscovery.com
Bali Hotels
Bali Villas
Bali Excursions
Bali Spas
Bali Sports
Holiday packages for 3 days or more stay !
Bali Transportation
Bali Services
Bali News
Bali Practicalities
Bali Contact
Home
 
Bali Update
Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!
 
Feedback
"The Bali Update newsletter is very informative and I tip my hat to the composer and editor for writing such beautiful English. By itself "Bali Update" is a superb advertisement for Bali and its attractions."

Robert Rienstra
Send us your [Feedback]!
 
Bali Reasons
Committed to
Customer Satisfaction

Should the occasion arise, every customer complaint is personally handled by one of Bali Discovery's Directors.
More good [Reasons]?
 
Bali Contact
Bali Discovery Tours
Komplek Pertokoan
Sanur Raya No. 27
Jl. By Pass Ngurah Rai,
Sanur, Bali, Indonesia

Tel: ++62 361 286 283
Fax: ++62 361 286 284
24h: ++62 812 3819724

Bali Discovery

SITE PATA ASITA
VisaMasterCardAmerican Express
 
 
Bali News
A Warning About Warnings
Editorial: There's Little Rhyme or Reason to How the Australian Government Structures its Travel Warnings.

Bali News: A Warning About Warnings
(1/20/2007) If you meet an Australian traveler and he or she seems a little confused, be sure to cut them a little slack. That befuddled state of mind is the natural result of trying to decipher and understand the current load of travel warnings posted by the Australian Government at [www.smarttraveller.go.au]

The Levels of Warning

By way of background, the Australian Government classifies every destination in the world under one of five levels of danger, ranking from the "safest" to the "most hazardous" with the following respective ratings:

"A" - Be alert to your own security

"B" - Exercise caution

"C" - High degree of caution

"D" - Reconsider your need to travel

"E" - Do not travel

The World as The Australian Government Sees It

A quick jump around all the countries and travel advisories listed on the smarttraveller.gov.au website suggests that Australian taxpayers may be getting precious little for the money they pay for thoughtful travel advice from Canberra.

Here's a sampling of the inconsistencies served up to Australians considering a globe-trotting walkabout.

Thailand "C" High Degree of Caution

Despite a series of bomb attacks on crowded public places in Bangkok on New Year's Eve and the recent coup, Thailand, as a whole, warrants the "average" or "neutral" rating of "High degree of caution".

Southern Thailand "D"- Reconsider Your Need to Travel

The Country's South, where almost daily attacks continue and nearly two thousand people have died in bombings, shootings and decapitations over the past two years gets the "D" rating of "Reconsider your need to travel" - putting that very troubled area where even school teachers are allowed to carry guns on an equal footing with Bali.

Spain "B" Exercise Caution

The bombing of Madrid's Barajas Airport on December 20, 2006, signaled an end to a six-month cease fire between the Spanish government and Basque separatists while re-opening the probability of future ETA attacks on public places. Add to this Spain's vulnerbility to violent attacks by radical Islamists, as demonstrated by the March 2004 Madrid train attack that injured over a thousand and killed 192 people, and you might wonder how the Australian Government manages to bestow upon Spain its tame "B" ranking of "exercise caution."

United Kingdom "B" Exercise Caution

Rated equally with Spain is the United Kingdom which also gets a "B" security rating of "Exercise Caution", despite the widely-held perception that the U.K. remains extremely vulnerable to terrorism following the July 2005 attacks on London's public transport and the Blair government's continued support of the Bush Administration's military intervention in Iraq.

Underlining the idiocy inherent in how Australia's appraises security is the the fact that Britian's MI5 doesn't share Canberra's optmistic view on security, choosing instead to issue a "D" or "Severe - an attack is highly likely" rating for the U.K. on its official website.

Indonesia "D" Reconsider Your Need to Travel

Earning a ranking just one step above the very worst "no go" warning possible from Canberra is Indonesia and the island of Bali.

Despite John Howard's lavish praise for Indonesia's leading role in the "war on terror" and the fact that terror attacks in Bali and Jakarta now pre-date similar attacks in London and Madrid, Indonesia and Bali still remain in the "dog's house" when it comes to Australian travel advisories.

Reflecting the lack of careful thought Australian bureacrats invest in formulating their Indonesian travel warnings, the smarttraveller.gov.au advisory current(sic) for January 14, 2007 still states: "There is a credible threat of terrorist attack in Indonesia during the Christmas and New Year period."

Unless the Australians now celebrate the Christmas holidays at a later date than the rest of the world, this warning is wrong on several levels.

United States "A" Be Alert to Own Security

And, as a final rebuttal to any lingering doubts that Australia's travel warnings have more to do politics than any objective review of security threats, consider the case of the United States which earns Australia's "safest" grade-"A" rating of "Be alert to your own security."

Supporting the view that Australian travel advisories are capriciously constructed is the simple fact that Canberra's "A" appraisal of overall U.S. Security is even more bullish than the "C" or "Elevated" rating America's own Department of Homeland Security gives to the current domestic security situation in the U.S.A., not to mention the even more foreboding "D" or "High - Orange" alert for the U.S. airline sector from Homeland Security.

While Washington diplomatically defers American travelers to Australia's self-assesment on security issues, Canberra seemingly knows better than even Washington when it comes to U.S. security, as revealed in its puppy-like eagerness to ingratiate itself with the Bush Administration.

Warning: I'm from the Government and I Want to Help You

Are Australian travel advisories politically motivated?

Naw . . . do you think?

© Bali Discovery Tours. Articles may be quoted and reproduced if attributed to http://www.balidiscovery.com. All images and graphics are copyright protected.

 
Bali News by Bali Update
Subscribe to the Bali Update
Receive the latest news from Bali by email!

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter and receive every Monday the latest information from the Island of the Gods.

Simply enter your email address below and join the community of more than 15,000 readers of Bali's only weekly newsletter.

Our [Privacy Statement] explains how we handle the data you are providing.

 
Bali News by Bali Update
Explore the Archive of the Bali Update
Find related articles in our news archive!

The Bali Update is published since more than 8 years. Thousands of articles are waiting for your exploration.

Simply enter your search terms below and travel back in time with Bali's most popular newsletter:

Home · Bali Hotels · Bali Villas · Bali Excursions · Bali Sports · Bali News · Site Map

Bali News: More News
How to Change Bali's Money Changers
Bali's Police Chief Growing Increasingly Annoyed with Abracadabra Money Changers.
(2/3/2007)
A Bali Warning: Bring Grandma Along
Indonesia Earns Robert Pelton's 'Vacations with Grandma' Travel Safety Rating.
(2/3/2007)
One Flu Over the Cuckoo's Nest
Bali Officials Increasingly Concerned Over Threat of H5N1 Virus.
(2/3/2007)
Four Seasons to Host 1st Bali International Triathlon
1st Bali International Triathlon on June 24, 2007 to be Headquartered at Award-Winning Four Seasons Resort at Jimbaran Bay.
(2/3/2007)
I Know What You'll Be Doing Next Summer!
International Doorways Offers Unique 27-Day Summer Program for High School Students in Bali July 9 August 27, 2007.
(2/4/2007)
We Think We Can, We Think We Can
Vice-President's Call for Ambitious Foreign Tourist Targets in 2007 Prompts Statements of Conditional Support from National Tourism Leaders.
(2/3/2007)
Air Paradise Offers Majority Stake to Bali Government
Airline Re-Launch Includes Plans to Fly to Australia and at Least 4 Domestic Destinations in Indonesia.
(2/3/2007)
Indonesia Appoints Meeting Czar
New Appointment to Assist Indonesian Bid for Major Conferences and Conventions.
(2/3/2007)
Bali to Host World Federation of Tourist Guides in 2009
Bali Beats Out Macau and Singapore for World-wide Gathering of Professional Tourism Guides.
(2/3/2007)
Taking Care with Carrefour
Local Leaders Keeping an Eagle-Eye on Carrefour Hypermarket Development.
(2/3/2007)
'Red Tide' Hits Bali's Western Shore
Thousands of Dead Fish Wash Ashore Near Tabanan Following 'Red Tide' Poisoning.
(2/3/2007)
We've All Gone to Look for America
Bali by the Numbers: At Home and Abroad American Arrivals Aren't What They Used to Be.
(2/4/2007)
All [News]!