Close
Bali Discovery Tours: Homepage
Bali Hotels, Bali Villas and Bali News from balidiscovery.com
Home Bali Contact Bali Practicalities Bali News Bali Services Bali Transportation Bali Sports Bali Excursions Bali Villas Bali Hotels
Home · News · Editorial: In Support of Reciprocity
Bali Hotels, Bali Villas and Bali News from balidiscovery.com
Bali Hotels
Bali Villas
Special Deals!
Packages
MICE Handling
Bali Excursions
Culinary - Dining
Guided Tour
Bali Spas
Bali Sports
Diving
Golf
Bali Transportation
Car Rental - Selft Drive
Private Jet Charter
Bali News
Bali Services
Bali Practicalities
Bali Contact
Bali Career
Home
 
Bali Update
Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!
 
PATA header
PATA Gold Award 2007
Bali Update
PATA Gold Award Winner 2007
 
Bali Contact
Bali Discovery Tours
Komplek Pertokoan
Sanur Raya No. 27
Jl. By Pass Ngurah Rai,
Sanur, Bali, Indonesia

Tel:
++62 361 286 283

Fax:
++62 361 286 284

U.S.A. Fax:(toll free)
1-800-506-8633

U.K. Fax:
++44-20-7000-1235

Australian Fax:
++61-2-94750419

24h:
++62 812 3819724

Bali Discovery

SITE PATA ASITA
Bali News

Editorial: In Support of Reciprocity

balidiscovery.com Takes a Different Perspective on Reciprocity and the Coming Changes to Indonesia's Visa Policy.


Bali News: Editorial: In Support of Reciprocity
Click Image to Enlarge

(4/28/2003)

Indonesia's Minister for Justice and Human Rights, Yusril Ihza Mahendra, widely seen as the architect of the Presidential Decision to revoke the visa-free-on-arrival and replace it with a "purchased" visa issued at the port of arrival, has steadfastly maintained that security and reciprocity are the drving principles behind the new policy. Minister Mahendra has, in fact, defended his desire to charge for visas saying "it's a big revenue source." Other countries generate revenue from it, so why don't we?"

Playing the nationalist card, the Minister has pandered to the populist political gallery, positioning himself as a champion of those many Indonesians who have been subjected to an expensive, time consuming and often humiliating visa application process required by many nations. Apparently the Minister's "tit-for-tat" logic is that if Indonesians are compelled by foreign governments to stand in line and pay for tourist visa, then Indonesia should similarly reciprocate in the way they treat visiting tourists.

Reciprocity Revisited

Beyond the obvious arguments that the change in visa policy will prove disastrous for Indonesia's tourism industry already teetering on the brink of collapse, we contend that the Minister's understanding of reciprocity is somehow sorely lacking in both vision and clarity.

Reciprocity can be view from two different perspectives: human rights and trade.

The human right's viewpoint – on the most basic level adopted by Minister Yusril, seemingly contends that because Indonesians are suffering due to policies that complicate their access to foreign countries, those wishing to visit Indonesia should be similarly inconvenienced by the new visa rulings.

There's something peculiarly provincial in the view that "misery loves company" and the way to respond to insensitivity and racial profiling from foreign nations is to quickly whip up our own local brand of the same.

While we share the Minister's indignation and irritation with the way some nations handle visa applications from traveling Indonesians, we wonder if the interests and comfort of the Indonesian traveling public might not be equally served by the removal of the current Rp. 1 million (approximately US$ 112) exit tax? This substantial amount, charged by the Indonesian government to every Indonesian and foreign resident traveling overseas, represents a substantial inconvenience to those seeking to holiday, study or seek medical attention abroad.

To our knowledge, the Minister has made no call for the revocation of the Rp. 1 million "fiskal" departure tax.

Reciprocity as a Trade Issue

In fact, if reciprocity is viewed from the wider perspective of international trade, the line between the "good guys" and the "bad guys" in the current debate become very blurred.

Imagine the hue and cry if Minister Yusril's counterparts in Singapore, Australia, Japan, the U.K. and the United States decided - in the name of "reciprocity" - to suddenly introduce a tax of $112 on every one of their citizens destined to Indonesia on a holiday and maintained that tax until such a time as Indonesia removed their similar "tariff barrier" to international tourism. Were such a policy introduced, it would further cripple Indonesia's already badly damaged tourism industry and be the death knell for hotels and tourism enterprises in Indonesia's resort islands in close proximity to Singapore.

In short, the arguments in support of the new visa policy, like the policy itself, warrant an urgent critical rethink. And, in the midst of the current international crisis in travel, Indonesia's leaders would best look for ways to cooperate internationally in overcoming our difficulties, abjuring the confrontational style inherent in their current understanding of the principal of reciprocity.



© Bali Discovery Tours. Articles may be quoted and reproduced if attributed to http://www.balidiscovery.com.


 
UBUD WRITERS & READERS FESTIVAL
 
Bali News by Bali Update
Subscribe to the Bali Update
Receive the latest news from Bali by email!



Our [Privacy Statement] explains how we handle the data you are providing.

 
Bali News by Bali Update
Explore the Archive of the Bali Update
Find related articles in our news archive!




or try to use Google Search :

Home · Bali Hotels · Bali Villas · Bali Excursions · Bali Sports · Bali News · Site Map · RSS

Bali News: More News
Plain Spoken about Tourism
President-elect Joko Widodo Speaks to Bali About Tourism
(9/1/2014)
Bali Training the World’s Green Leaders
UN Secretary Ban Ki-Moon Visits Bali’s Green School and Praises it Revolutionary Commitment to Sustainability
(9/1/2014)
Walk a Mile in Their Shoes
Macbeth Footwear Teams Up with Solemen to Donate Shoes for the Poor
(8/31/2014)
Gypsy at the Wheel
Widespread Violation of Laws on Taxi Meter Use Damaging the Reputation of Bali as a Tourism Destination
(9/1/2014)
It's a Jungle Out There
Denpasar Zoning and Building Authorities Falling Miserably in the Enforcement of the Law
(9/1/2014)
Tough Rules for Hotel Permits in Kuta, Bali
Bali Stops Hotels on Postage Stamp-Sized Pieces of Land in Kuta
(9/1/2014)
For Fans of Fantinel
Six Outstanding Courses and Paired Wines from Fantinel of Northeast Italy at Ju-Ma-Na Restaurant – Banyan Tree Ungasan, Bali on Friday, September 19, 2014
(8/31/2014)
A Park for Pedestrians
Pedestrian Underpass at Ngurah Rai Monument at Bali Airport Set to Open in Early 2015
(8/31/2014)
We've Got Rhythm!
Bali's Famous and Inspiring Kecak Dance Has a Rich and Varied History
(8/31/2014)
Run for Someone Else’s Life
14th Chapter of Hard Rock Hotel Bali Rock ‘N Run 5 Kilometer Fun Run Sunday, November 2, 2014
(8/31/2014)
In Style and Safety to Gili Trawangan
Bounty Cruises Mounts Luxury Daily Departures from Bali to Gili Trawangan
(8/29/2014)
In Urgent Need of Connections
PLTU Celukan Bawang Aiming to Start Producing Electrical Power for Bali in December 2014 - a Year Behind Schedule
(8/31/2014)
All [News]!
 
Tourism and Transport Tourism Agents