Close
Bali Discovery Tours: Homepage
Bali Hotels, Bali Villas and Bali News from balidiscovery.com
Home Bali Contact Bali Practicalities Bali News Bali Services Bali Transportation Bali Sports Bali Excursions Bali Villas Bali Hotels
Home · News · Editorial: Bali Tourism & Taxes
Bali Hotels, Bali Villas and Bali News from balidiscovery.com
Bali Hotels
Bali Villas
Special Deals!
Packages
MICE Handling
Bali Excursions
Culinary - Dining
Guided Tour
Bali Spas
Bali Sports
Diving
Golf
Bali Transportation
Car Rental - Selft Drive
Private Jet Charter
Bali News
Bali Services
Bali Practicalities
Bali Contact
Bali Career
Home
 
Bali Update
Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!
 
PATA header
PATA Gold Award 2007
Bali Update
PATA Gold Award Winner 2007
 
Bali Contact
Bali Discovery Tours
Komplek Pertokoan
Sanur Raya No. 27
Jl. By Pass Ngurah Rai,
Sanur, Bali, Indonesia

Tel:
++62 361 286 283

Fax:
++62 361 286 284

U.S.A. Fax:(toll free)
1-800-506-8633

U.K. Fax:
++44-20-7000-1235

Australian Fax:
++61-2-94750419

24h:
++62 812 3819724

Bali Discovery

SITE PATA ASITA
Bali News

Editorial: Bali Tourism & Taxes

While Local Debate Rages on New Ways to Tax Bali's Tourists, The Real Solution May Be that Less is More.


Bali News: Editorial: Bali Tourism & Taxes
Click Image to Enlarge

(9/14/2001)

Bali economist, Dr. Nyoman Erawan speaking at a seminar in Bali (12/9) on "Controlling the Cumulative Effect on the Environment" resurfaced the suggestion, popular in some circles, that tourists to Bali should be charged an "environment" or "culture" tax in order to provide badly needed revenues to local government authorities. Dr. Erawan argued that a 2.5% tax on all tourism expenditures would help compensate Bali for the indirect subsidies enjoyed by tourists in the form of government subsidies on gasoline, power and basic food stuffs.

While no one can argue against the fact that tax revenues contributed by tourism have an important role to play in Bali’s public sector economy, government officials should exercise extreme caution before increasing taxes on the tourism sector. Get it wrong, and Bali will become uncompetitive in comparison to the professionally promoted neighboring destinations in the region.

Let’s not lose note of that fact that taxes levied on tourists are, in a very fundamental way, voluntary taxes. Tax visitors to the point that a destination is seen as poor value for money, and the tourist start taking their money and their holidays elsewhere.

A high tax rate on a small tax base could mean imprudently applied additional taxes for Bali is a zero sum game.

Tourism: Already a Major Source of Tax Revenue

Bear in mind that tourists visiting Bali already pay a very substantial tax contribution. A 10% local development tax is applied on hotel and restaurant bills; value added taxes are applied on many purchases made by visiting tourists ranging from local tours to purchases made at Bali’s supermarkets; wages paid at local establishments made possible by the spending of Bali's visitors are subject to payroll taxes; corporate profits from tourism enterprises incur taxes up to 35%; and, lastly, before leaving the country tourists will pay a final Rp. 75,000 airport service charge before boarding their flight home.

Let’s Sort out the Current Tax Mess First

A strong argument can be made that the real problem in terms of Bali's taxation collection is not one of a lack of taxes on visiting tourists but the current grossly inefficient system of collection. The long-ranging public debate in Bali's Parliament has made no secret of the fact that tax calculation on the island is a moveable feast in which entrepreneurs negotiate with the tax collectors. The ensuing three-way tug-of-war invariably results in the public getting the shortest end of the stick.

Unsurprisingly, officials are often reluctant to reveal the amount of tax collected and when they do, the amount reported seem very inadequate in comparison with the size of the island’s tourism industry. To cite one illustrative point, the Bali Post carried the story several months ago of how a popular locally owned hotel paid only Rp. 20 million in the mandatory 10% local development tax for a single year. Meanwhile, a foreign-managed hotel in Nusa Dua, paid a Rp. 25 billion tax bill for the same period. The legislators, according to the paper, were openly bemused that a successful hotel, by extrapolation, had only achieved a total annual turnover of US$ 20,000.

The story in other areas of tax collection - from airport departure taxes, fiscal levies on departing residents, to securing a new driving license is, sadly, much the same. The amount of total revenues collected in taxes have little rhyme or reason with collectors enjoying wide ranging powers to negotiate and finalize tax settlement with local business people.

First Things First

While we have the ultimate respect for Dr. Erawan's skill as an economist, there seems little point in introducing new tax sources for Bali until the current system of tax collection is revamped and upgraded. We suggest, in fact, that with a few simple improvements in how tax revenues are collected the total money available to the public form taxes on the tourism might increase dramatically, making the environment tax suggested by Dr. Erawan completely unnecessary.

The Answer: Transparency

A straight-forward solution on how to collect more tax revenues is available, providing the island's leaders have the political will to do the "right thing."

For a start, if all taxes collected from local restaurants and hotels were published in the local press once a year it’s conceivable that the amount of tax collected would suddenly undergo a dramatic increase. The open publication of taxes paid by each hotel and restaurant would destroy any existing incentives to seek special treatment from local tax officials. Entrepreneurial pride and civic duty would make it difficult for business people to understate their sales when they knew such figures would eventually be published side-by-side with the total tax contribution of their competitors. Additionally, employees of those same enterprises would offer another form of effective control as they would compared tax payments with the similar 10% service charge paid to them by most hotels and restaurants. And, finally, perhaps the best argument for the transparent publication of an annual business by business listing of taxes paid is that such a list would also provide the total tax revenues available to local government for expenditure on public projects, a question heretofore shrouded in mystery.

It's really that simple and, We guess, also that difficult. All that's lacking is sufficient political will to do the "right thing" for both Bali and its future.


© Bali Discovery Tours. Articles may be quoted and reproduced if attributed to http://www.balidiscovery.com.


 
 
Bali News by Bali Update
Subscribe to the Bali Update
Receive the latest news from Bali by email!



Our [Privacy Statement] explains how we handle the data you are providing.

 
Bali News by Bali Update
Explore the Archive of the Bali Update
Find related articles in our news archive!




or try to use Google Search :

Home · Bali Hotels · Bali Villas · Bali Excursions · Bali Sports · Bali News · Site Map · RSS

Bali News: More News
Heinz's 100 Varieties of Indonesian Cuisine
Bookshelf: A New Approach to Indonesian Cooking by Heinz von Holzen
(10/20/2014)
We Get More Mail!
Folly has its Price. Spirited Comments of Disaffection Continue to Flow in About Bali’s Newly Renovated Airport
(10/20/2014)
Who Owns Bali’s Heritage
Legality of Badung Regency Funding of Taman Ayun Questioned by Badung Legislator
(10/19/2014)
The Gods Must be Irritated
French Climber Evacuated From Upper Slopes of Mount Agung
(10/20/2014)
Sauvetage en Mer
Bali Lifesavers Show Their Skills at International Surf Rescue Games in France
(10/19/2014)
Chefs Al Fresco in Sanur Bali
Bali Culinary Professionals to Meet at Swiss-Belresort Watu Jimbar on Saturday, October 25, 2014
(10/23/2014)
World Travel Agents to Meet in Bali
United Federation of Travel Agents to Meet in Bali November 16-19, 2014
(10/19/2014)
Travel May be Ebola’s Biggest Victim
Editorial: In the Unfolding Ebola Epidemic Crisis the Most Deadly Symptom May be Fear
(10/20/2014)
Human Charity – On the House
‘Together as One’ Fun Run Raises More than US$9.000 to Improve Housing for the Poor in Bali
(10/19/2014)
Passing Gas
Denpasar, Bali Mayor Joins Chorus Urging Port of Benoa Not be Used for LNG Depot
(10/19/2014)
Ignoring the Protests
Tirta Wahana Bali International to Go Ahead with Benoa Bay Reclamation Project
(10/19/2014)
Ease of Access
Indonesia Fails to Enforce Rules on Handicapped Access
(10/18/2014)
All [News]!